Forum The Longship So much for Geno

So much for Geno

Vikesrock
Joined Jan 2014
84 posts
Rep: 179

Adam Schefter
@AdamSchefter
Trade: the Raiders are sending QB Geno Smith and a 2026 7th-round pick to the New York Jets in exchange for a 2026 6th-round pick, per ESPN sources. Smith returns to the team for which he started his NFL career for in 2013.

I hate this.  I hate that Murray is the target.  Same ol crappy Vikings move.  Sign some retread, half ass in to the playoffs...lose, but Murray good enough to sign for 2027.  Miss out on any draftable QB's.  Let JJM go.  2027 is a disaster as Murray reverts back to suckatude.....

Liked:
#1 · Mar 10, 8:32 AM
Kentis
Joined Oct 2013
797 posts
Rep: 943

I bet he’s thrilled…!  :P

Liked:
#2 · Mar 10, 8:36 AM
JR44
Joined Aug 2017
636 posts
Rep: 848

Wonder if AZ has not released Murray yet, because they are trying to do the same thing.

Liked:
#3 · Mar 10, 8:45 AM
comet52
Joined Sep 2013
706 posts
Rep: 1,050
Vikesrock wrote:
I hate this.  I hate that Murray is the target.  Same ol crappy Vikings move.  Sign some retread, half ass in to the playoffs...lose, but Murray good enough to sign for 2027.  Miss out on any draftable QB's.  Let JJM go.  2027 is a disaster as Murray reverts back to suckatude.....
Catastrophizing on overdrive!

Well there's always Kirko if Kyler ain't it. :shy:

Or maybe the return of Daniel Jones for huge $$$. Talk about catastrophes.

Liked:
#4 · Mar 10, 8:51 AM
purplefaithful
Joined May 2013
7,592 posts
Rep: 4,174
JR44 wrote:
Wonder if AZ has not released Murray yet, because they are trying to do the same thing.

100% why...And this is where the Colts, Steelers or CLE could grab the inside track on MN for Murray (if he is a consideration for us). 

Would you give up a late rd pick for him? 

If he is their guy then maybe they do???

Hurry-up Vikings, we ain't getting any younger! 

Liked:
#5 · Mar 10, 8:51 AM
Kentis
Joined Oct 2013
797 posts
Rep: 943
purplefaithful wrote:

100% why...And this is where the Colts, Steelers or CLE could grab the inside track on MN for Murray (if he is a consideration for us). 

Would you give up a late rd pick for him? 

If he is their guy then maybe they do???


Not w/ hi$ contract…!  :s

edited Mar 10, 2026 8:54 AM
Liked:
#6 · Mar 10, 8:52 AM
comet52
Joined Sep 2013
706 posts
Rep: 1,050
purplefaithful wrote:

100% why...And this is where the Colts, Steelers or CLE could grab the inside track on MN for Murray (if he is a consideration for us). 

Would you give up a late rd pick for him? 

If he is their guy then maybe they do???

You don't just give up a late round pick, you also pay the 37 million instead of the vet minimum.  Teams in play for Kyler are just going to wait it out then hope he picks them--if those details weren't already worked out at the combine.  He's worth a cheap flyer, but paying all that money doesn't make sense.

Liked:
#7 · Mar 10, 8:54 AM
purplefaithful
Joined May 2013
7,592 posts
Rep: 4,174
Kentis wrote:
Not w/ hi$ contract…!  :s

Lol you're right! 

never mind

Hurry-up Vikings, we ain't getting any younger! 

Liked:
#8 · Mar 10, 8:55 AM
comet52
Joined Sep 2013
706 posts
Rep: 1,050
StickierBuns wrote:

So many good options! ;)

Or.....OR....you go all in on JJ's development and let him be QB1 for 2026 and lets see how much he's improved. 

*I* could do lots of stuff but... WWKD? (What would Kevin do?)  I think he's seized control over at TCO because he thinks JJM might be the end of his job.  And here we are in the quarterback of the month club.  JMO.

Stupidity.
Did I mention Kevin?  :P
Liked:
#9 · Mar 10, 9:06 AM
SA
Joined May 2013
143 posts
Rep: 102
StickierBuns wrote:

 Every Kyler Murray highlight fest I see from national talking heads just shows him scrambling, running around and throwing some hero ball jump balls. Whoop-de-do. Where's the pocket precision? 

Liked:
#10 · Mar 10, 9:21 AM
purplefaithful
Joined May 2013
7,592 posts
Rep: 4,174
StickierBuns wrote:

No, I disagree about KOC being stupid. I don't think he's anything of the sort. I do think he's trying to figure out how to win now and still keep JJM as The Man. I think you either are both feet in or out. I think he's still smarting from letting both Uncle Sammy and Danny Dimes go....who actually let them go I don't know. 

I'm an O'Connell fan....but if he makes Murray QB1 I'm going to really question my thoughts on that subject.

I think (strongly suspect?) KAM put KOC and that coaching staff in a real bad position in 25...

I believe the stories that KOC didnt believe JJM was ready yet, not after a rook season spent in re-hab.

edited Mar 10, 2026 9:23 AM

Hurry-up Vikings, we ain't getting any younger! 

Liked:
#11 · Mar 10, 9:22 AM
Vikesrock
Joined Jan 2014
84 posts
Rep: 179
StickierBuns wrote:

So many good options! ;)

Or.....OR....you go all in on JJ's development and let him be QB1 for 2026 and lets see how much he's improved. You know, the guy you moved up for to take 10th in the Draft? The guy that was 6-4 in starts? I'm all for upgrading the QB room, yes please, but behind JJM. Every Kyler Murray highlight fest I see from national talking heads just shows him scrambling, running around and throwing some hero ball jump balls. Whoop-de-do. Where's the pocket precision? Oh yeah, he's 5'10" standing on the greater New York area phone book.

Stupidity.

I keep going back to the definition of insanity.  If we sign Murray, isn't it Brett Farve, Sam Darnold year 1, Sam Bradford, Kirk Cousins....  We are just a QB away.....

AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!

Let JJM play.  If he can't, draft Arch Manning...NEW plan...NEW

Sorry, my VTSD (Vikings Tramatic Stress Disorder) is kicking in hard today.

Liked:
#12 · Mar 10, 9:38 AM
purplefaithful
Joined May 2013
7,592 posts
Rep: 4,174
Vikesrock wrote:

I keep going back to the definition of insanity.  If we sign Murray, isn't it Brett Farve, Sam Darnold year 1, Sam Bradford, Kirk Cousins....  We are just a QB away.....

AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!

Let JJM play.  If he can't, draft Arch Manning...NEW plan...NEW

Sorry, my VTSD (Vikings Tramatic Stress Disorder) is kicking in hard today.

I might take a 2009 redux - with a happier ending. That was a f'ing fun ride, till it wasn't.

Hurry-up Vikings, we ain't getting any younger! 

Liked:
#13 · Mar 10, 9:39 AM
Vikesrock
Joined Jan 2014
84 posts
Rep: 179
savannahskol wrote:

One thing of note on this.  Every one of these has a big giant opening in front of him to throw through.  If I was an opposing defense, I would hire 4 Sumo wrestlers 6'8 to stand in front of him and then just give them a sandwich or something.

purplefaithful wrote:

I might take a 2009 redux - with a happier ending. That was a f'ing fun ride, till it wasn't.

It was fun, until we unraveled at Arizona and Chicago the last couple weeks of the season, setting up New Orleans as the #1 seed.  Everyone fixates on the Farve interception, but the absolute ineptitude of the 12 man in the huddle after a time out...

I also remember 2010 was an unmitigated disaster..

edited Mar 10, 2026 9:42 AM
Liked:
#14 · Mar 10, 9:40 AM
MaroonBells
Joined Jan 2014
4,292 posts
Rep: 4,480
Vikesrock wrote:

I keep going back to the definition of insanity.  If we sign Murray, isn't it Brett Farve, Sam Darnold year 1, Sam Bradford, Kirk Cousins....  We are just a QB away.....

AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!

Let JJM play.  If he can't, draft Arch Manning...NEW plan...NEW

Sorry, my VTSD (Vikings Tramatic Stress Disorder) is kicking in hard today.

God I hope so! You say this like it's a bad thing. Favre had us in the NFCC, Darnold won 14 games, Bradford before he was hurt might have been the best QB play I've seen from a Viking since Culpepper, and Cousins was an MVP candidate before his achilles. If Murray gives us that, I'll take it!

Liked:
#15 · Mar 10, 9:56 AM
Vikesrock
Joined Jan 2014
84 posts
Rep: 179
MaroonBells wrote:

God I hope so! You say this like it's a bad thing. Favre had us in the NFCC, Darnold won 14 games, Bradford before he was hurt might have been the best QB play I've seen from a Viking since Culpepper, and Cousins was an MVP candidate before his achilles. If Murray gives us that, I'll take it!

Super Bowl or bust..I am tired of NFCC games and 14 win regular seasons.  Get one before I die...I am 2 cheeseburgers away as it is.

Liked:
#16 · Mar 10, 10:14 AM
StickierBuns
Joined May 2013
8,173 posts
Rep: 21
Kentis wrote:

I bet he’s thrilled…!  :P


lmao.
Liked:
#17 · Mar 10, 1:47 PM
StickierBuns
Joined May 2013
8,173 posts
Rep: 21
comet52 wrote:

Catastrophizing on overdrive!

Well there's always Kirko if Kyler ain't it.  :shy:

Or maybe the return of Daniel Jones for huge $$$.  Talk about catastrophes.


So many good options! ;)

Or.....OR....you go all in on JJ's development and let him be QB1 for 2026 and lets see how much he's improved. You know, the guy you moved up for to take 10th in the Draft? The guy that was 6-4 in starts? I'm all for upgrading the QB room, yes please, but behind JJM. Every Kyler Murray highlight fest I see from national talking heads just shows him scrambling, running around and throwing some hero ball jump balls. Whoop-de-do. Where's the pocket precision? Oh yeah, he's 5'10" standing on the greater New York area phone book.

Stupidity.
Liked:
#18 · Mar 10, 1:54 PM
StickierBuns
Joined May 2013
8,173 posts
Rep: 21
comet52 wrote:


*I* could do lots of stuff but... WWKD? (What would Kevin do?)  I think he's seized control over at TCO because he thinks JJM might be the end of his job.  And here we are in the quarterback of the month club.  JMO.

Did I mention Kevin?  :P


No, I disagree about KOC being stupid. I don't think he's anything of the sort. I do think he's trying to figure out how to win now and still keep JJM as The Man. I think you either are both feet in or out. I think he's still smarting from letting both Uncle Sammy and Danny Dimes go....who actually let them go I don't know. 

I'm an O'Connell fan....but if he makes Murray QB1 I'm going to really question my thoughts on that subject.
Liked:
#19 · Mar 10, 2:09 PM
StickierBuns
Joined May 2013
8,173 posts
Rep: 21

So Jordan Schultz reported that Minnesota had strong interest in Geno Smith, which I agree with. Maybe KOC hasn't lost his marbles completely.

Liked:
#20 · Mar 10, 2:46 PM
JimmyinSD
JimmyinSD
Admin
Joined May 2013
2,023 posts
Rep: 1,871

Kyler Murray’s accuracy stats when in the pocket are a key part of his performance profile, though they reflect both strengths and areas for improvement. 

Clean Pocket Completion Percentage: According to advanced metrics, Murray completed 70.6% of his passes when in a clean pocket, which ranks among the upper tier of NFL quarterbacks. This indicates solid accuracy when afforded time and protection.
Pass Accuracy and Target Depth: Despite his clean-pocket efficiency, Murray’s overall completion percentage (68.8% in 2025) is somewhat hindered by his average target depth of 7.1 yards, the 30th shortest in the league. This suggests he often throws short, high-percentage passes, which can inflate completion rates but limit explosive plays.
Inaccuracy Under Pressure: When pressured, his completion rate drops to 56.0%, highlighting vulnerability when the pocket collapses. This is a recurring concern, especially in games where pass protection falters.
Expected Completion Rate: In Week 1 of the 2025 season, Murray finished 3.9% below expected completion rate based on Next Gen Stats tracking data, indicating he missed several catchable throws, even in favorable situations. This suggests occasional inconsistency in timing and placement, particularly on deeper or contested routes.
Field Vision and Decision-Making: Some analysts note that Murray’s limited field vision—attributed to his height (5’10”) and release point—can lead to missed reads or forced throws, especially when he’s not scrambling. This is a noted concern in the pocket, where timing and sight adjustments are critical. 
In summary, while Murray shows strong accuracy in clean pockets, his overall effectiveness is tempered by inconsistencies under pressure, limited deep-ball success (25.0% deep ball completion rate), and occasional decision-making lapses, which remain focal points for improvement.

Why isn't Chuck Foreman in the Hall of Fame?

Liked:
#21 · Mar 10, 3:08 PM
Log in to reply.

Edit Post (mod action — author will see a notice)

Warn Poster

Suspend User (3 days)

The user will be suspended for 3 days and will receive an email with the reason and information about how to appeal.

Forum The Longship So much for Geno

Welcome to VikeFans!

Welcome back, Skol fans! This is our new home. Log in with your username or email and your existing password.


Be sure to check out the How To's and Questions forum for guides on getting around the new site, and use the Help Request forum if you run into anything that you need help with. Skol!